University of Wisconsin–Madison

Form I-9 Workday Guidance

   

New Terminology

In Workday, there are key terms that have new names. The chart below provides the original term and the new replacement term.

New Workday terminology
Original HireRight Term New Workday Term
Proxy Remote
Correct Amend
Supplement B Section 3
Delete Rescind
Proxy Representative Authorized Representative

I-9 Coordinator Role vs. I-9 Partner Role

Overview

This job aid outlines the responsibilities, tools, and procedures for I-9 Coordinators and I-9 Partners to complete their tasks effectively. It also explains the relationship between the I-9 Coordinator role and the I-9 Partner role, as well as when and how to contact OHR Compliance.  For more detailed information about what has changed in the processing of the Form I-9, please review Overview of Specific Actions for Form I-9 Processing.

I-9 Coordinator Role

This role performs transactional Form I-9 responsibilities for their assigned supervisory organization, including meeting new hires to complete Section 2, submitting the Final Authorization, completing Supplement B for rehires and reverifications, and entering external records of Form I-9s. 

I-9 Coordinators may include positions outside of human resources, such as:

  • Department Administrators
  • Payroll Coordinators
  • Managers
  • Student Help
I-9 Coordinator Responsibilities
Complete Section 2 of the Form I-9
  • Meet with new hires in person to verify their documents and complete Section 2 of the Form I-9.
  • Ensure that all necessary documentation is provided by the employee and reviewed for compliance.
Submit the Final Authorization
  • After completing Section 2, submit the Final Authorization for the Form I-9 process by selecting Employment Authorized.
Complete Supplement B for rehires, reverifications, and name changes
  • For rehires, fill out Supplement B of the Form I-9 to maintain proper records.

  • For reverifications, ensure that the employees employment authorization is still valid and updated.

  • For name changes, update the employees name if applicable.

Entering External Records of Form I-9s
  • For employees with Form I-9s completed in HireRight, enter the Form I-9 data from HireRight into Workday to ensure compliance is tracked.
  • If a paper Form I-9 is needed or on file, the paper Form I-9 must be uploaded to Workday. Instances in which a paper Form I-9 may be used or on file:
    1. Supplement B Reverification for an employee who requires reverification of their employment authorization documents but does not live near UW-Madison. An Authorized Representative must complete a paper Form I-9, send it securely to the I-9 Coordinator, and the I-9 Coordinator must upload it to Workday as an external record.

    2. Current employees who have a paper Form I-9 in Box. The paper Form I-9 in Box can be uploaded to Workday as an external record so the paper Form I-9 is stored in Workday.

Accessing the Form I-9 Compliance Dashboard
  • The I-9 Coordinator has access to the I-9 Compliance Dashboard where they can track the status of Form I-9s for their assigned supervisory organization.

Assigning and Inheriting Roles

  • The I-9 Coordinator role is assigned at the supervisory organization level. If not assigned to a subordinate organization, the role is inherited automatically by those organizations.

  • The role has transactional access limited to the assigned or inherited supervisory organizations.

Amending a Form I-9

  • The I-9 Coordinator can send back the Form I-9 until it is finalized. This includes the ability to send back Section 1 to an employee to update or to the Authorized Representative to update Section 2. Once the Form I-9 is finalized, the I-9 Coordinator cannot amend or send back. 
    • If the start date changes after the Form I-9 is completed, the I-9 Coordinator must notify an I-9 Partner to amend the start date on the Form I-9 and the I-9 Coordinator must notify the Shared Services Human Resources UW role to amend the start date on the worker profile.
I-9 Coordinator Key Tasks and Tools
Inbox Task for Section 2, Final Authorization, and Supplement B
  • The I-9 Coordinator will receive inbox tasks that prompt them to complete Section 2 and submit the Final Authorization. They will also handle Supplement B Rehires and Reverifications if necessary (e.g., for reverifications, rehires, name changes).
Supervisory Organization Assignment
  • The I-9 Coordinator role is assigned at the supervisory organization level and can be inherited by lower-level organizations. This ensures that the Form I-9 responsibilities are appropriately distributed.

I-9 Partner Role

This is a strategic role that manages the overall Form I-9 process. The primary responsibilities of this role include ensuring institution-wide Form I-9 compliance through audits and reports. This role can amend Form I-9s, initiate the standalone Form I-9 process, and cancel the Form I-9 business processes. I-9 Partners are individuals in OHR Compliance. This role is not assigned to an employee outside of OHR. 

When to Contact OHR Compliance

There are specific functions that only an I-9 Partner will be able to complete. Contact OHR Compliance if you need support with any of the tasks below.  

Functions that only an I-9 Partner will be able to complete
Amending a Form I-9
  • If an error has been made or an update is required on the Form I-9 such as a start date, document title, document number, etc. after the Form I-9 has been completed. 
  • The most common reason to amend a Form I-9 is the First Day of Employment (start date). This process does not amend the start date on the worker's profile. Only the Shared Services Human Resources UW role can amend the start date on the worker's profile. The I-9 Coordinator must notify an I-9 Partner to amend the start date on the Form I-9 and the I-9 Coordinator must notify the Shared Services Human Resources UW role to amend the start date on the worker profile.
Canceling a Form I-9
  • If a new hire will no longer be in the position, if a paper Form I-9 is being completed or if the employee will be working outside of the United States, the Form I-9 business process must be canceled.
Initiating a Standalone Form I-9
  • This is for cases where an employee is hired in Workday but their onboarding (and Form I-9 process) was skipped, or when a Form I-9 must be completed for an employee who does not have one on file.

Note: The Form I-9 process should be initiated through the onboarding system to avoid manual errors. A standalone Form I-9 should only be initiated if the onboarding process has not been completed, and this should occur on a very infrequent basis.

Form I-9 Responsibility and Access Chart

The following table further breaks down the responsibility and access based on role to provide a comparison. 

Form I-9 Responsibilities Chart 

Responsibility

I-9 Coordinator

I-9 Partner

Level/Hierarchy Assigned

Supervisory organization

Local (campus/institution)

Receives Task to Complete Section 2

Yes

No

Receives Task to Complete Supplement B for rehire

Yes

No

Receives 90, 60, 30 day notifications of upcoming expiring documents needing reverification

Yes

No

Can access a Form I-9 to complete a reverification

Yes

Yes

Can complete record of external Form I-9 and external Form I-9 Supplement B

Yes

Yes

Can amend Form I-9 after the Form I-9 is completed

No

Yes

Initiate a Form I-9 outside of onboarding

No

Yes

Can view reports on the Form I-9 Dashboard

Yes

Yes

Can view the Onboarding Business Process Status Summary Report

Yes

No

Can delegate assigned Form I-9 responsibilities

Yes-per delegation rules

Yes-per delegation rules

Can reassign Form I-9 responsibilities

Yes-to those with existing security

Yes-to those with existing security

Form I-9 Reports in Workday

The following reports can be used to ensure compliance with Form I-9s.

  • I-9 Authorization Status (UW): Report identifies the Authorization Status for Form I-9, including the workflow steps in progress and who owns the next step.
  • I-9 In Progress Status (UW): Identifies in progress Form I-9s and includes worker name, hire date, due date and who is responsible for the next step.
  • I-9 Questionnaire Responses (UW): This report provides questionnaire results from the Form I-9 questionnaire answered during the hire process.
  • I-9 Section 1 Overdue (UW): Identifies overdue Form I-9s with incomplete Section 1 and includes worker name, due date, and days past due.
  • I-9 Section 2 Overdue (UW): Identifies overdue Form I-9s with incomplete Section 2 and includes worker name, due date, days past due, and the I-9 Coordinator assigned.
  • I-9 Section 1 Still In-Progress (UW): Identifies Form I-9s that have a Section 1 status of in progress and includes worker name, date of hire, due date, and status description.
  • I-9 Section 2 Still In-Progress (UW): Report identifies Form I-9s with Section 1 with a completed status and Section 2 with a status of in progress.
  • Audit Form I-9
  • Audit Form I-9 Receipts
  • Form I-9 Audit Trail: View the audit trail of Form I-9 business processes for one or more organizations, locations, establishments, or workers. Details include the business process initiate date, initiator, and status of individual business process steps.
  • Form I-9 Internal Audits
  • Form I-9 Process Status: This report provides a count of Form I-9 business processes in various statuses.
  • U.S. Electronic Form I-9 Verifications
  • Mass Print Form I-9 for Workers: Prints all Form I-9 documents for worker. Facets you can select for the report are location, supervisory organization, worker is active, and worker has Form I-9.
  • Expiring Form I-9 Documents (UW): This report is used to track expiring documents on the Form I-9.
  • U.S. Employees with Form I-9 Expiring Documents: View U.S. employees with expiring Form I-9 Section 2 and Supplement B documents that require reverification.
  • U.S. New Hires Missing an Electronic Form I-9
  • Most Recent Form I-9 Validation (UW): This report is used for validation of the most recent Form I-9s attached to a worker.

Guidance for Processing Form I-9s between HireRight and Workday

After the transition to Workday, there may be Form I-9s in HireRight that require completion in Workday. The following scenarios provide information as to how to handle these unique situations and ensure compliance and proper processing of Form I-9s.

Workday cutover scenarios
Scenario Process Steps
Audit Reveals Missed Rehire from Form I-9 in HireRight for an Active Appointment
  • Email OHR Compliance at hrcompliance@ohr.wisc.edu to initiate a standalone Form I-9 in Workday using the rehire date that was missed.
  • Use the overdue reason of: Audit Revealed that New Hire Was Not Run.
  • Add the termination date to the Form I-9 in HireRight corresponding to the previous positions termination date.
New Hire
  • A Form I-9 is initiated in Workday as part of the onboarding process.
Supplement B Reverification Needed from Form I-9 in HireRight

When the I-9 Coordinator receives a notification reminder from HireRight that an employee's employment authorization documents are expiring, the following steps must be completed in Workday:

  • If there is an external record in Workday of the Form I-9 data from HireRight, a Supplement B Reverification can be completed via the external record.
  • If there is not an external record in Workday, it must be completed in Workday before a Supplement B Reverification can be completed. When creating the external record, the I-9 Coordinator must use the Form I-9 data from HireRight. The I-9 Coordinator should include all relevant Form I-9 data such as document title and document expiration date. Once the external record is completed, the Supplement B Reverification with the updated employment authorization can be completed via the external record. Please review the Complete Record of External Form I-9 Knowledge Base for instructions on how to create an external record. 
  • If an employee is outside of Madison and an Authorized Representative will be needed, a paper Form I-9 must be used and the I-9 Coordinator must create an external record in Workday and upload the paper Form I-9. Please review the Complete Record of External Form I-9 Knowledge Base for instructions on how to create an external record. 

Note: Supplement B Reverifications that converted from HireRight to Workday cannot be reported on for reverification purposes because data about the documents and their expiration dates are not converting. Therefore, it is important to continue to run reverification reports in HireRight and ensure the Hiring Manager in HireRight is updated because Workday will not send notification reminders when an employment authorization document is set to expire from a converted external record.

Note: Form I-9 documents must be inspected in-person. 

Rehire Needed Due to Break-in-Service and Form I-9 in HireRight is within USCIS Guidelines
  • If there is an external record of a Form I-9 that was originally completed within three years of the rehire date, the I-9 Coordinator will receive a task to complete Supplement B, or alternatively, initiate a new Form I-9 as part of onboarding. A new Form I-9 should be selected for all rehires who have not completed a Form I-9 in Workday. 
  • If there is not an external record, a new Form I-9 will be initiated as part of onboarding. 
    • If a new Form I-9 was not initiated as part of onboarding, email OHR Compliance at hrcompliance@ohr.wisc.edu to initiate the standalone Form I-9 business process. 
  • Add the termination date to the Form I-9 in HireRight corresponding to the previous positions termination date.

Form I-9 Data Converted into Workday Guidance

Data from Form I-9s completed outside of Workday can be put into Workday in two ways:

  1. Mass conversion of data from HireRight and FormI9.com as part of the Workday implementation (Form I-9s completed on paper will not be converted).
  2. Adding data from individual Form I-9s using the Complete Record of External Form I-9 and Complete Record of External Form I-9, Supplement B (formerly Section 3) tasks.

Note: Data from Form I-9s converted into Workday are not a replacement for the original forms. The original forms, whether electronic or paper, are considered the complete Form I-9 and must be retained according to USCIS requirements.

Data Conversion - Implementation

Included in the Workday implementation is a mass conversion of Form I-9 data from records in HireRight and FormI9.com. This includes both Section 1 and Section 2 data, as well as Supplement B (formerly Section 3). Given the number of Form I-9s and the differences between the prior systems and Workday, not all pertinent Form I-9 data can convert into Workday. 

Data not converted includes:

  • Paper Forms: Mass conversion of hard copy/paper Form I-9s was determined out of scope for Workday implementation.   
  • Form I-9s for Terminated Employees: Workday only allows Form I-9s for active employees. Form I-9s for terminated employees that are within the record retention period or have not been purged will not have data converted.
  • Form I-9s for current Contingent Workers: If a current Contingent Worker has a Form I-9 because they were previously an employee, that Form  I-9 data will not be converted.
  • Optional data: Not all data points included on the Form I-9 are required for conversion.  The following data points have been excluded as part of the Workday implementation:
    • Employee Address, Email Address, and Phone Number in Section One
    • Alien Registration Number, USCIS Number, I-94 Admission Number, Foreign Passport Number and Country of Issuance in Section One
    • Translator Data
    • Issuing Authority information in Section Two
    • Employer Business Title, Name, and Address in Section Two
    • E-Verify information
    • Attachments
    • Expiration Dates for documents are not required but will be converted where possible
    • Section 3/Supplement B data conversion is minimal with only the Employee Name, Name of Employer or Authorized Representative, and Date of Employer Signature data points converted

Note: Form I-9 data from the HireRight and FormI9.com reports used in the conversion process that do not meet the criteria for conversion or where the conversion into Workday fails, will be collected in Error Reports. Campuses will be provided with the relevant Error Reports and can determine if and how they would like to address the errors.

Data Conversion – Enter External Record Ad Hoc

Those assigned the I-9 Coordinator or I-9 Partner security roles have the ability to create a record in Workday of a Form I-9 that was completed outside of Workday. Two tasks are available to add individual data from an external Form I-9 to a worker in Workday. The available data fields will align with the Form I-9 most recently published by USCIS, but they are not all required to create the record.

The Tasks & Required Data

Complete Record of External Form I-9: Add Form I-9 data from Section 1 and Section 2 of an external form.

At minimum, the following data fields must be populated:

  • External Record Source: Options are HireRight, FormI9.com, and Paper
  • Section 1: Last Name of Employee
  • Section 1: First Name of Employee
  • Section 1: Employee Attestation to Citizenship or Immigration Status
  • Section 2: At least one document title
  • Section 2: Employee's First Day of Employment
  • Section 2: Employer or Authorized Representative Signature Date

Complete Record of External Form I-9, Supplement B (formerly Section 3): Can only be used in relation to a complete record of external Form I-9 (which must be loaded/added first).

The only required data field for this task is: Employer or Authorized Representative Signature Date.

How Converted Data in Workday Functions

Converted Form I-9 data does not have the same functionality as data entered as part of the Complete Form I-9 or Complete Form I-9, Supplement B (formerly Section 3) business processes.

Reports: Converted Form I-9 data can appear in reports but the usability will be determined by what data is included.

Example: If a converted record only includes the Document Title from Section 2 and not an expiration date, it cannot be tracked on the Expiring Form I-9 Documents report for reverification. 

Audits: The Form I-9 data in Workday from an external record is not a complete Form I-9.  Converted data can be viewed and audited internally but would not be sufficient in the case of an external audit.

Supplement B (formerly Section 3): The Complete Form I-9 Supplement B (formerly Section 3) task can be initiated when an external record of Form I-9 has been added to Workday.  However, Workday provides the following note as part of this process:

Sections 1 and 2 shown here are blank because they relate to a Form I-9 that exists outside of Workday for this worker. To proceed with reverification, complete Section 3 and submit. Section 3 will be linked to Sections 1 and 2 of the Record of the External Form I-9 in Workday

The original/complete Form I-9 should always be reviewed before completing Supplement B when Section 1 and 2 are from an external record. 

Amend Form I-9: Amending records of external Form I-9 records are not supported.

 

Updated: Jun. 06, 2025
Source URL: https://hr.wisc.edu/hr-guides/for-hr-professionals/form-i-9-workday-guidance/

Did you find what you need?